Tag Archives: Sarah Afshar

What Can We Learn From Keenan Vanginkel’s Work Records?

Over the past week or two, Toni Ingram has tried to perpetuate the idea that in the days prior to Morgan Ingram’s death, an arrest of Keenan Vanginkel was imminent.

On July 9, 2013 Toni Ingram wrote:

Keenan would know that the record of his hours working for City Market was going to be handed over the Sheriff’s department the following week.  Not only did the Detective think that, “if anything, the stalking was going to escalate.”  He would ask for, and receive increased patrols, an extra one or two a night.  And they would all be 100% focused up on our roof.  What did they find out?  And why did they not share it with us?  http://morganingram.com/wordpress/?p=4169

On June 14, 2013 Toni wrote:

  • Nov 29, 2011 – before 5:00 PM Detective Glassmire is over at our house and tells me that he is 100% certain that Keenan Vanginkel is the stalker.
  • Nov 29, 2011 – before 5:00 PM Detective Glassmire tells me that he believes the stalking is going to escalate.
  • Nov 29, 2011 – before 5:00 PM Detective Glassmire tells me that he will be picking up Keenan’s work record from City Market that coming Tuesday (same day Morgan is due to give her official statement), and when he overlays that work schedule with my timeline he is confident he will be very close to making an arrest for Felony Stalking. http://morganingram.com/wordpress/?p=4058

The above statement (in bold) got me thinking.

According to Toni and Steve Ingram, police dropped the stalking investigation like a bad habit after Morgan died.  However, detectives did pick up Keenan’s work records, as evidenced by their presence in the supplemental reports.  This tells me that on Tuesday December 6, 2011 police were still looking at Keenan Vanginkel in relation to the stalking of Morgan Ingram. Why didn’t detectives make the follow-up arrest Toni writes about?  According to Toni the only thing police had to do was compare Keenan’s work schedule with her timeline and Keenan would be arrested for felony stalking.  So what happened?  Why was there no arrest?

It doesn’t take a genius to realize the work records/timeline overlay was not the smoking gun for which the Ingrams hoped.

Curious to see what was learned from the side by side comparison,  I decided to create one.

A couple of things stand out:

First is how quickly the Ingrams concluded Morgan was being stalked.  Only seven days passed between the day Morgan returned from California and the purchase of the outdoor motion alarm.  In that seven day period there is one event that stands out. and that’s the hard bang on the bathroom window after Morgan closed it.

Second is the degree in which the work records exculpate Keenan Vanginkel.  They clearly show Keenan could not be responsible for some of the most significant events, including the night the “stalker” was photographed in the driveway.

A few notes on formatting:

These were done in Excel and converted to .pdf (Acrobat Professional).  and .jpg. The conversion from Excel is quirky so readers might notice some appearance issues here and there. For best viewing,  I recommend downloading the pdf files   However, I realize some people are not comfortable doing that, so I’ve provided .jpgs that can be viewed in the browser.

I have tried to be as accurate as possible and have double, triple, and sometimes quadruple checked all sources. It is a work in progress.  Readers please let me know if you notice any errors.

This is the data for August and September 2011.  I will upload October and November/December as soon as there finished.

Direct download:

Comparison of Keenan Vanginkel’s time sheet to Toni Ingrams stalker timeline.

Image

Image

August 22, 2011 Upon further reflection, I should have made the Aug 22 event reported in the blog teal rather than green.  Toni said she woke to the sound of the lock beeping.  The reliability of something Toni heard while asleep is suspect.

August 30, 2011 In her blog Toni places the date they captured the stalker on wildlife camera as Aug 29, 2011.  This is somewhat misleading. The incident that prompted the call to police occurred on the 29th and the call to dispatch was logged at 23:55 or 11:55 PM.  Dispatch notified officers at 1:05 AM and officers report they arrived at the Ingram home at 1:20 AM.  Unfortunately, things get muddy from here.  The timestamp on the wildlife cam picture shows the first deputy leaving at 00:43 which is 12:43 AM. The next picture shows two more deputies leaving at 00:44 or 12:44 AM.  This begs the question, how could police be leaving at 12:45 AM if they didn’t even arrive until 1:20 AM?  The”stalker” picture is stamped 00:46 or 12:46 AM. The final picture is what Toni says is the stalker trying to break the camera.  That picture is stamped 00:48 or 12:48 AM.  Obviously someone’s time line is not correct.  I think we can all reasonably conclude whose interest would be served by altering the time.  However, it could also be a simple mistake.  In the end it is irrelevant.   Keenan Vanginkel could not be in two places at once.  He couldn’t be on the Ingram’s roof at 12:48 AM trying to knock down the camera and punching in at work exactly 10 minutes later.

Sept 3, 2011 When police were called about the Sept 5 incident Toni reports they went to the Harris home and spoke with Brooke.  This is also detailed in the police report.

Brooke spoke with the deputy but told him Keenan was asleep and therefore not available.  Toni did not believe Brooke and felt she was covering for Keenan.

I’ve worked hours similar to Keenan’s the majority of my adult life.  Based on my own experience, alongside info shared by coworkers, it is my opinion that Keenan was quite likely sleeping, just as Brooke said.

Let’s look at Keenan Vanginkel’s schedule:  On 9-3-2011  Keenan got off work around lunch time.  He probably went home, ate lunch, watched TV or played video games or something similar in an attempt to unwind.  He may have tried to take a nap.

He probably experienced some difficulty if he did try to sleep because doing so would go against his body’s natural circadian rhythm.  Later as the sun went down, his pineal gland would begin to secrete melatonin and already sleep deprived from working nights, he most likely couldn’t keep from falling asleep until he had to go to work.

This is only my opinion, but as I said, it comes from 20 years of personal experience.  When I worked midnights it was always my habit to go to sleep after dinner and then wake and go right into work.  Consequently, the statement that Keenan was asleep doesn’t strike me as unusual.

Labor Day Weekend  I’ve colored these events yellow because no time is given for the reported events.

Clueless

Yesterday, May 20,2013, Toni Ingram tweeted 14 “clues” that she apparently thought were significant in relation to her daughter’s death.  By definition a clue is something that serves as a guide or aid in the solution of a problem or mystery.  Following that definition, these aren’t really clues.  None of these lead anywhere.

Below are Toni’s clues followed by my response.

Quotes are written by Toni Ingram and posted @morgansstalking:

https://twitter.com/morgansstalking

Clue #1 Amitriptyline [sic] in the stomach is not related to PMR but Amitriptyline [sic] in the blood is subject to PER [sic]

Clue #2 How could a person have a blood level of 7900+ng in her blood, when 1,000 ng is lethal?

Clue #3 the amount of Amitriptyline [sic] in Morgan’s stomach fluid was not enough to kill her, but that is what the pathologist based suicide on

Clue #4 if you were a Forensic Toxicologist you would know why the date rape drugs in Morgan’s stomach fluid never made it in to her blood especially because one of those date rape drugs would have gone into the blood at the same time as the Amitriptyline [sic]

Clue #5 The Pathologist that did Morgan’s autopsy blames PMR for her high reading, but PMR kicks in at 24 hrs & goes for the next 24 hrs.

Clue #6 Pathol. est. Morgan took 18 pills, only accts for Ami in gastric not the 7909ng/ml found in her blood. 18-25 mg pills not lethal

I have grouped these first six together since they all concern amitriptyline.

This has all been addressed before, much of it in a previous blog, What Dr. Kurtzman Knew.  Either she does not understand the science or she refuses to accept it.  Toni claims they have consulted with several medical professionals but I find that claim highly suspect.  These first six “clues” show a complete lack of understanding for even basic pharmacology and organic chemistry.

One more time for those who joined us late:

Toxicity and absorption of drugs cannot be discussed without a basic understanding of pharmacogenetics.

Pharmacogenetics is the study of genetic differences that affect an individual’s response to certain drugs. Different drugs undergo different metabolisms as a result of genetic variation, especially in the cytochrome p450 family of enzymes.  My point?  There are no absolutes.  It’s impossible to know Morgan’s cardiotoxic level without knowing if she was or was not deficient in the cytochrome P450 enzyme.

Cardiotoxic levels of amitriptyline generally occur between 450 ng/ml to 1,000 ng/ml.  Okay, so how did Morgan end up with a postmortem level of 7909 ng/ml.

First it is essential to understand that when medical professionals talk about the cardiotoxic level they mean antemortem, prior to death.  Antemortem levels are based on plasma, which is prepared by spinning down a fresh whole blood sample to remove the red blood cells, white blood cells, and platelets. From a pharmacokinetic perspective, red blood cells, white blood cells, and platelets are a tissue compartment.

As I mentioned in What Dr. Kurtzman Knew, amitriptyline is highly lipophilic (lipo=fat + philic=love of) and found in greater concentrations in both fat and protein than in plasma.  The human body begins autolysis, the breakdown of tissue, at the moment of death (the idea that this process waits 24 hours and ends 24 hours later, is laughable).  Amitriptyline, resides mostly in deep tissue compartments and is released into whole blood.

The result is the levels in the whole blood, which is what is used for a postmortem sample, will reflect concentrations from tissue, red blood cells, white blood cells, and plasma and range from 5 to 10 times higher than the antemortem plasma concentration. In addition, there may be redistribution from other tissue compartments into the blood as the body decomposes.

Clue #6 [sic]  Morgan had an overkill dose of drugs in her blood, but no container or syringe was found anywhere in her room or in the house.

The “container” was the pill bottle next to her bed.

Clue #7 Morgan’s nails were torn on her right hand 1-1/2 years later nobody in GarCo can produce a picture from the crime scene of her nails.

According to the medical examiner, her nails were intact when Morgan left his morgue.

Case #11-29169

Det. Sergeant D. Breier

Unattended Death Report

She exhibited a small amount of blood in her mouth [pulminary edema]. There was a very small red mark on the right side of her forehead [lividity]; otherwise there was no apparent evidence of external trauma

Case # 11-29169

Detective J. A. LeMoine

Unattended Death Report

Once the Coroner arrived on scene the towel covering Morgan’s upper portion of her body was removed. Video and photographs of Morgan’s body were taken at this time. I did not observe any signs of trauma on Morgan at this time.

Clue #8 ALL of her jewelry of value went missing on the night she was killed while her #stalker frequents cash for gold establishments.

Toni concluded Morgan’s jewelry was missing only after she heard Keenan was picked up on a theft warrant.  These charges were later dropped.

Case #11-20197

Det. Robert Glassmire:

I explained to Toni that if she wants to report a theft of Morgan’s jewelry I would be happy to assist with that and either generate a new case or add it to the ongoing stalking case. I then told her that she would have to complete a list of stolen items and that she could not look at a list of items and determine what had been stolen from that list.

It should be noted that there is no information to believe that Keenan Vanginkel has stolen any of Morgan Ingram’s jewelry. Furthermore, Toni or Steve Ingram have yet to provide me with a list to base a theft report on.

Clue #9 Morgan’s #panic button was torn from its mount on her nightstand and found hidden in her room.

We only have Toni’s word on this and we all know what that’s worth.

Clue #10 The rain gutter directly over Morgan’s bedroom window was torn in half by repeated bending by her #stalker leaning over the edge!

The gutter was discovered long after the Ingram’s moved from the house.  If someone was leaning on the gutter it would bend, sag, or pull away from the house.  The gutter over Morgan’s windows appears split on a seam

Clue #11 Morgan’s room was completely disheveled with obvious signs of a struggle having taken place there

Case # 11-29169

Detective J. A. LeMoine

Unattended Death Report

During this time I observed that Morgan’s bedroom was disorganized with clothing and other items covering the majority of the floor. I observed that the adjoining bathroom to Morgan’s bedroom was in the same condition.

Did the struggle continue into the bathroom?   If Morgan fought off an attacker to the point that it left her room in disarray (Det. Sergeant Breier called it slovenly), how is it she bore no defensive wounds and her body showed no signs of trauma?  How is it this struggle was not heard by Steve and Toni Ingram?

Clue #12 Figures are caught three times outside the house by video surveillance on the night Morgan was killed.

Case #11-29169

Supplemental report #2

Det. Sergeant D. Breier

The residence has an installed video surveillance systems recorded by a DVR. The video was reviewed which showed the decedent (identified as Morgan Ingram) returning home around 2100 hours. There was no further activity until the decedent’s mother moved the vehicle she had parked in the driveway so emergency responders could access the house

Clue #13 The next door neighbor reported odd things going on in Morgan’s bathroom the night she was killed – but was never questioned

How did the neighbor know what happened in Morgan’s bathroom?  Surely Morgan would have her blinds drawn/shade pulled down etc.

Clue #14 Why would a person that does not know Morgan or her family & wasn’t involved in her stalking/murder be so invested in lying?

First:  I have never lied about Steve, Toni, or Morgan Ingram, Keenan, Brooke, or anyone else connected to this tragedy.  The Truth for Morgan group has NEVER harassed or bullied Steve or Toni Ingram or any of their supporters.  We don’t have to slander Jodin Davunt, Sarah Afshar, or Mark Mann et al.  They have successfully made themselves look far worse than we ever could.

When I discovered distortions and outright lies in the Morgan’s Stalking blog, lies of which Toni was made aware, I delayed exposing her faux pas, to give her every opportunity to correct or retract her mistakes (she didn’t).  Furthermore, I use proper blogging etiquette and strikethrough if I have to make changes, unlike Toni who completely deletes and rewrites posts on a whim.

Essentially Toni is asking why we we would bother to stick up for someone (Keenan Vanginkel) we do not know personally. In my opinion her inability to grasp the why factor is telling.

Toni Ingram has made it her life’s mission to ruin the lives of others based on faulty logic and substandard science.  There is absolutely no evidence that Keenan stalked or murdered Morgan, but that doesn’t matter to Toni.  She slanders and accuses any and all who dare to disagree with her, unfettered by morals or conscience.  The young people Toni bullies have barely crossed into adulthood.  Life is hard; Competition for opportunities to advance is greater than it ever was.  Toni Ingram is robbing these kids of their futures and limiting their opportunities by besmirching their names.

Someone has to stand up to her and say enough is enough

Why?  Because it is the right thing to do……

It’s that simple

The REAL Truth About Keenan Vanginkel’s Criminal History

May 13, 2013

By Shelby

Surprise!  Keenan Vanginkel’s criminal history barely resembles Toni Ingram’s description.

On 10 May 2013 Toni Ingram wrote:

http://morganingram.com/wordpress/?p=3762

Which brings up the third piece of advice which I have found to be a very informative, and a useful tool – that is to get the criminal records of the stalker, especially a stranger stalker.  As the claims that he has never been in trouble in his life grow ever louder from all of his family, the list of charges, for a twenty-one year old seem very, very, long.  And most all of the charges he has been found guilty of portend to a serious problem if connected with a stranger stalker, as they are in Morgan’s case.

Toni has written several times about Keenan’s so called criminal record. In the above quote and in previous blogs, she has consistently presented it as extensive.  Although she has not made that record available via Morgan’s Stalking, she has shared it through her Twitter sock account (@SupportIngrams) and with her Twitter followers  They in turn have made it publicly available through their hate sites and Twitter pages.  Readers who wish to see it may do so at one of the following Twitter account pages:

https://twitter.com/SupportIngrams (this is Toni Ingram)

https://twitter.com/JDForJustice  

https://twitter.com/RiversShanna

It is located in the left hand column under “view all videos and photos.”

Here is the problem with this document:

It is not Keenan Vanginkel’s criminal record.

What Toni Ingram calls an extensive criminal record is actually a global subject activity report.   

The global subject activity report is a record of a citizen’s interaction with law enforcement.  The activity report can contain items unrelated to criminal activity.  For example, if I am a witness to a car accident or if I am stopped for speeding and given a warning, or even if I am the victim of a crime,  it would all be entered on my  global subject activity report,   A glance at Keenan Vanginkel’s GSAR shows multiple items where criminal charges weren’t applicable, including an impounded vehicle, witnessing a crime, and a trespassing accusation on Aug 25, 2011 courtesy of the Ingrams. 

Last week I ordered a copy of Keenan Vanginkel’s criminal history; his real criminal history.  I ordered it from CBI which is the agency Toni repeatedly has said should have been brought in to investigate Morgan’s death. 

Click here to see Keenan’s true criminal record.

Not exactly the record of a criminal mastermind ninja stalker.

I know I shouldn’t be surprised at the level to which Steve and Toni Ingram will sink, yet I am.  I just don’t understand what is wrong with these people.  How can Steve and Toni, along with those who actively lie on their behalf, stand the very sight of themselves? 

Just one last thing.

Of what charge was Keenan found guilty that “portends” predicts, foretells, prognosticates, or adumbrates, pick a word any of them will do, “a serious problem” if connected to a stranger stalker?  Tell us Toni, which one of Keenan’s crimes do you consider the great harbinger of future stalking events?  Was it the marijuana possession or was it the drug paraphernalia charge? 

If smoking pot leads to stalking, most residents of Colorado should watch their backs; they could find themselves on someone’s suspect list.

image

Looks Like I Struck a Nerve in Montana or Colorado

Thank you for providing the doctors names.  You can bet I will be contacting every one of them to confirm they are acting as consultants to the Ingrams.

Oh by the way, I’ve never lived in a trailer park but I don’t look down on those who do.  I have a high school diploma, not a GED, but again, I don’t look down on people who had to go that route for whatever reason.  Morgan Ingram was a non-traditional student and GED recipient if I recall.

I have never nor would ever “dub myself as smart.”  Intelligence (or lack of) is obvious.  People will make that determination based on what they are shown, not what they are told..

Tweets From Jodin Davunt:

Jodin’s mom and dad must be proud. /sarcasm

Actually, as a parent, I feel badly for Jodin’s parents, Michael Patrick Davis and Renee Suzannah Trunt (DAVis + trUNT = Davunt)  Not because their thirty-some year old son is divorced, living in their basement, and working a dead end job, All parents want their children to be financially independent and successful, but material possessions don’t really matter.  When it’s all said and done, parents want to know their children are kind, honest and decent people.  Jodin’s parents don’t have that comfort.

Whereabouts Still Unknown

Exploring new avenues in the search for missing persons

HardballTalk

Baseball. Baseball. And then a bit more baseball.

Book Journey

Continuing adventures of a true bookaholic...

Debunking Denialism

Fighting pseudoscience and quackery with reason and evidence.

Michigan is Amazing

Showing the world that Michigan is Amazing!

TED Blog

The TED Blog shares interesting news about TED, TED Talks video, the TED Prize and more.

The Context Of Things

Ted Bauer's blog about leadership, marketing, the future of work, and his own misguided life.

Truth For Morgan Too

TFM Tumblr On Wordpress

Steve Huff's Blog

Current events, history, and other bad ideas, from an unreliable narrator (formerly known as HuffWire)

Meg Investigates

Exploring Life off the Beaten Path